Text-only version of this email
Five Great Reads: why some books are beyond help, plus arguments about happiness and apples | Australia news | The Guardian
11 % Guardian Five Great Reads
... we have a small favour to ask. For more than 200 years, we’ve been delivering fearless, independent journalism for millions of
readers around the world. As a reader-funded organisation, we rely on your generosity to keep our quality reporting open and free
for everyone, including newsletters like this one. If you can, please support us today from just $1. Thank you.
Support the Guardian
FIVE GREAT READS: WHY SOME BOOKS ARE BEYOND HELP, PLUS ARGUMENTS ABOUT HAPPINESS AND APPLES
Guardian Australia’s weekend wrap of essential reads from the past seven days, selected by Imogen Dewey
* Get this in your inbox every weekend. Sign up for Five Great Reads here.
Cezanne, Paul (1839-1906): Still Life with Fruit Dish, 1879-80 New York Museum of Modern Art (MoMA)
‘Sorry Cézanne, but still lifes are dull as hell’ … is the view of one of our writers. Not mine. Pictured: a detail from Cézanne’s
Still Life with Fruit Dish (1879-80). Photograph: The Museum of Modern Art, New York/Scala, Florence
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Imogen Dewey
IMOGEN DEWEY
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sydney, where I’m writing this from, is having a late, baking burst of summer: in the evenings, bats and rats flit across my back
yard (by sky and fence, respectively), lazy shadows jagging towards the last of the light. In the bright, cicada-filled mornings,
people plan how they might make the most of – or avoid – the sun, drink their coffee, and stand squinting at the lights, idly
thumbing over their phones and trying to make sense of the week.
And what a week: (another) bad one for banks! Some very expensive boats for Australia! An Oscar for Paul Keating! A ratpocalypse
for Paris! An OnlyFans doppelganger for … Adrian Chiles?
If this dizzying agenda has you worried you’re out of touch with current affairs, consider signing up for the daily Morning Mail
or Afternoon Update. If, on the other hand, you’re happy letting the distant echoes of global events filter through to you as they
will … stay here, read these stories instead.
1. THE GREAT SEROTONIN DEBATE
An interesting instalment from our How to have a healthy brain series looks at the hotly contested role of the chemical –
sometimes labelled the “happy hormone” – in depression. As Hannah Devlin writes, “the idea of a chemical imbalance is embedded in
public consciousness and has shaped the way we view mental illness”. But, spoiler, the bigger picture is more complicated.
How long will it take to read: a bit under five minutes.
Further reading: try another one from the series, Don’t forget to floss: the science behind dementia and the four things you
should do to prevent it – this by our UK science editor, the pleasingly named Ian Sample.
2. A JOB AFTER DEATH
People protest for the demarcation of Indigenous land and over the murder of Dom Phillips and Bruno Pereira in São Paulo in June
2022.
People protest for the demarcation of Indigenous land and over the murder of Dom Phillips and Bruno Pereira in São Paulo in June
2022. Photograph: Cris Faga/NurPhoto/REX/Shutterstock
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read Jonathan Watts’s account of a memorial mass for in the Brazilian forest city of Anapu – “one of the most murderous
municipalities on Earth … [where] much of the violence is related to disputes over land”.
Watts’s mate, British journalist Dom Phillips, was murdered last year alongside Brazilian Indigenous expert Bruno Pereira, joining
hundreds “in the pantheon of martyrs of the rainforest”. Their faces frequently adorn protest shirts and banners, their deaths now
another flashpoint for environmental and political debate.
For Watts, seeing his old friend’s image at the service is “at once horrifying, uplifting and surreal”: a friend who “was very
much of the view that journalists should never become the story”, who was keenly aware of the many killings never investigated or
covered by media – but who, for better or worse, has brought renewed global attention to a constantly roiling conflict.
A shocking stat: according to Global Witness, Watts notes, at least 1,733 people have been murdered since 2012 trying to protect
land and resources – “an average of one killing every two days”.
How long will it take to read: a bit less than three minutes.
3. SOMETHING TO PONDER ON THE WHOLE GARY LINEKER THING
For my sins, I did not until last week know who Gary Lineker was. Obviously, I do now. (TLDR: beloved football presenter tweets
reasonable thing about inhumane UK – Oz-inspired! – policy, huge backlash ensues as he is taken off-air then put back on again.
Sign up to those news briefings if you’d like to know more about these things as they unfold).
Jonathan Liew’s piece took a pithy look at what the whole scuffle (re)exposes about “the chimera of impartiality” surrounding
institutions like the BBC – why we buy in, locally or globally; why we might, one day, eventually stop doing that.
In a line: “This has always been a playground of establishment power, and yet if the surreal last few days teach us anything it is
that the terms of engagement may be shifting.”
How long will it take to read: two minutes.
4. SOME BOOKS ARE BEYOND A SENSITIVITY READ
Jan Grue as Ivar Salvesen (right) in Occupied
Jan Grue as Ivar Salvesen (right) in Occupied. ‘The series was set in modern, progressive Norway, so no one referred to my
character as a “cripple” or with any other kind of slur. That did not change the essential fact of characterisation. And no
sensitivity reading on the verbal, or even conceptual level, could change that.’ Photograph: Yellow Bird/Netflix
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
“As a wheelchair user, I could not help noticing that the original Bond books had, shall we say, an interesting relationship to
embodied difference,” writes Jan Grue. “Fleming’s attitude to disability was encoded not only in words and phrases, but in
characterisation and plot – that is, in the stories’ most fundamental qualities.”
Grue makes a fantastic close read of what’s really at play when we’re talking about dated attitudes in storytelling. And then
returns to a point that’s been made again and again: you can re-edit old stories, but only to a certain point. At a certain point,
you can just read (and assign on courses, and make movies of) other books.
Why his perspective is extra interesting: Grue played a political assistant to the fictional PM in a Norwegian TV series – and as
drafts of the show progressed, realised his character was “joining the ranks of Dr Strangelove and the usual wheelchair-using
baddies”. Not shockingly, no one else really seemed to see this as an issue.
How long will it take to read: seven-and-three-quarter minutes.
5. ARE STILL LIFES (LIVES??) BORING?
Hannah Jane Parkinson takes the occasion of a blockbuster at the Tate Modern to point out that maybe there are more interesting
things to paint than apples (something Cézanne did more than 270 times, apparently) – or still life generally. She gives a pass to
flowers, kitchen-scapes and Martin Parr’s baked beans. And to the artists giving still life a more contemporary valency: coffee
cups, headphones, face masks. But makes an entertaining argument that there are better things to put to canvas.
Still, I just don’t agree with her on the fruit. Fruit is pleasing. So much so that people buy fake versions of it. A source of
rich emotional material, and in fact one of the best subjects to evoke “the feeling of summer warmth on your skin”. To her claim
that: “A banana has not fallen in love with other fruits; experienced joy or loss,” I would simply say she has clearly never been
to a show where a mime makes several bananas act out a dramatic break-up scene and murder at the club – something I experienced
earlier this year, weirdly compelling.
How long will it take to read: three-and-a-half minutes.
SIGN UP
Enjoying the Five Great Reads email? Then you’ll love our weekly culture and lifestyle newsletter, Saved for Later. Sign up here
to catch up on the fun stuff with our rundown of must-reads, pop culture, trends and tips for the weekend.
Guardian newsletters offer an alternative way to get your daily headlines, dive deeper on a topic, or hear from your favourite
columnists. We hope this brings something different to your day, and you’ll consider supporting us.
For more than 200 years, we’ve been publishing fearless, independent journalism on the events shaping our world. Now, with a daily
readership in the millions, we can bring vital reporting to people all around the world, including emails like this, direct to
your inbox.
As a reader-funded news organisation, we rely on the generosity of those who are in a position to power our work. This support
protects our editorial independence, so our reporting is never manipulated by commercial or political ties. We’re free to report
with courage and rigour on the events shaping our lives. What’s more, this funding means we can keep Guardian journalism open and
free for everyone, regardless of their ability to pay for it.
If you share in our mission for open, independent journalism, and value this newsletter, we hope you’ll consider supporting us
today. If you can, please support us on a monthly basis from just $2. It takes less than a minute to set up, and you can rest
assured that you’re making a big impact every single month in support of open, independent journalism. Thank you.
Support the Guardian
Manage your emails | | Trouble viewing? You are receiving this email because you are a subscriber to Five Great Reads. Guardian
News & Media Limited - a member of Guardian Media Group PLC. Registered Office: Kings Place, 90 York Way, London, N1 9GU.
Registered in England No. 908396
Show all