Hackaday

Hackaday Newsletter 0xAE

Hackaday sent this email to their subscribers on October 4, 2024.

To Make an Apple Pie from Scratch, Must You First Create the Universe?
HACKADAY

Java Ring: One Wearable to Rule All Authentications Read Article Now»

Where is the End of DIY?

By Elliot Williams

Al and were talking on the podcast about Dan Maloney’s recent piece on how lead and silver are refined and about the possibility of anyone fully understanding a modern cellphone. This lead to Al wondering at the complexity of the constructed world in which we live: If you think hard enough about anything around you right now, you’d probably be able to recreate about 0% of it again from first principles.

Smelting lead and building a cellphone are two sides of coin, in my mind. The process of getting lead out of galena is simple enough to comprehend, but it’s messy and dangerous in practice. Cellphones, on the other hand, are so monumentally complex that I’d wager that no single person could even describe all of the parts in sufficient detail to reproduce them. That’s why they’re made by companies with hundreds of engineers and decades of experience with the tech – the only way to build a cellphone is to split the complicated task into many subsystems.

Smelting lead is a bad DIY project because it’s simple in principle, but prohibitive in practice. Building a cellphone from the ground up is incomprehensible in principle, but ironically entirely doable in practice if you’re willing to buy into some abstractions.

Indeed, last week we saw a nearly completely open-source build of a simple smartphone, and the secret to making it work is knowing the limits of DIY. The cell modem, for instance, is a black box. It’s an abstract device that you can feed data to and read data from, and it handles the radio parts of the phone that would take forever to design from scratch. But you don’t need to understand its inner workings to use it. Knowing where the limits of DIY are in your project, where you’re willing to accept the abstraction and move on, can be critical to getting it done.

Of course, in an ideal world, you’d want the cell modem to be like smelting lead – something that’s possible to understand in principle but just not worth DIYing in practice. And of course, there are some folks out there who hack on cell modem firmware and others who could do the radio engineering. But despite my strong DIY urges, I’d have to admit that the essential complexity of the module simply makes it worth treating as a black box. It’s very probably the practical limit of DIY.

From the Blog


Polaris Dawn, and the Prudence of a Short Spacewalk

By Tom Nardi

Is it a spacewalk if you only stick your head out? Tom argues that it's a good first step. Read more »

Mining and Refining: Lead, Silver, and Zinc

By Dan Maloney

Where do we get lead from? Dan tells all! Read more »

Static Electricity And The Machines That Make It

By Lewin Day

From a little shock or a bolt of lightning, Lewin goes over your choices for making sparks. Read more »

Hackaday Podcast

Hackaday Podcast Episode 291: Walking in Space, Lead in the Earth, and Atoms under the DIY Microscope

By Hackaday Editors

What happened last week on Hackaday? The Podcast will get you up to speed.  Read more »

If You Missed It


Dog Poop Drone Cleans Up the Yard So You Don’t Have To

Building a 3D Printed Scanning Tunneling Microscope

Supercon 2023: Thea Flowers Renders KiCad Projects On The Web

2024 SAO Contest: We’ve Got SAOs for your SAOs

Pi Zero Power Optimization Leaves No Stone Unturned

Hackaday

NEVER MISS A HACK

Hackaday.io

Hackaday.com

This email was sent to

why did I get this?

Hackaday.com · 61 S Fair Oaks Ave Ste 200 · Pasadena, CA 91105-2270 · USA

Text-only version of this email

To Make an Apple Pie from Scratch, Must You First Create the Universe? HACKADAY Java Ring: One Wearable to Rule All Authentications Read Article Now» WHERE IS THE END OF DIY? By Elliot Williams Al and were talking on the podcast about Dan Maloney’s recent piece on how lead and silver are refined and about the possibility of anyone fully understanding a modern cellphone. This lead to Al wondering at the complexity of the constructed world in which we live: If you think hard enough about anything around you right now, you’d probably be able to recreate about 0% of it again from first principles. Smelting lead and building a cellphone are two sides of coin, in my mind. The process of getting lead out of galena is simple enough to comprehend, but it’s messy and dangerous in practice. Cellphones, on the other hand, are so monumentally complex that I’d wager that no single person could even describe all of the parts in sufficient detail to reproduce them. That’s why they’re made by companies with hundreds of engineers and decades of experience with the tech – the only way to build a cellphone is to split the complicated task into many subsystems. Smelting lead is a bad DIY project because it’s simple in principle, but prohibitive in practice. Building a cellphone from the ground up is incomprehensible in principle, but ironically entirely doable in practice if you’re willing to buy into some abstractions. Indeed, last week we saw a nearly completely open-source build of a simple smartphone, and the secret to making it work is knowing the limits of DIY. The cell modem, for instance, is a black box. It’s an abstract device that you can feed data to and read data from, and it handles the radio parts of the phone that would take forever to design from scratch. But you don’t need to understand its inner workings to use it. Knowing where the limits of DIY are in your project, where you’re willing to accept the abstraction and move on, can be critical to getting it done. Of course, in an ideal world, you’d want the cell modem to be like smelting lead – something that’s possible to understand in principle but just not worth DIYing in practice. And of course, there are some folks out there who hack on cell modem firmware and others who could do the radio engineering. But despite my strong DIY urges, I’d have to admit that the essential complexity of the module simply makes it worth treating as a black box. It’s very probably the practical limit of DIY. FROM THE BLOG - POLARIS DAWN, AND THE PRUDENCE OF A SHORT SPACEWALK By Tom Nardi Is it a spacewalk if you only stick your head out? Tom argues that it's a good first step. Read more » MINING AND REFINING: LEAD, SILVER, AND ZINC By Dan Maloney Where do we get lead from? Dan tells all! Read more » STATIC ELECTRICITY AND THE MACHINES THAT MAKE IT By Lewin Day From a little shock or a bolt of lightning, Lewin goes over your choices for making sparks. Read more » Hackaday Podcast HACKADAY PODCAST EPISODE 291: WALKING IN SPACE, LEAD IN THE EARTH, AND ATOMS UNDER THE DIY MICROSCOPE By Hackaday Editors What happened last week on Hackaday? The Podcast will get you up to speed.  Read more » IF YOU MISSED IT - DOG POOP DRONE CLEANS UP THE YARD SO YOU DON’T HAVE TO BUILDING A 3D PRINTED SCANNING TUNNELING MICROSCOPE SUPERCON 2023: THEA FLOWERS RENDERS KICAD PROJECTS ON THE WEB 2024 SAO CONTEST: WE’VE GOT SAOS FOR YOUR SAOS PI ZERO POWER OPTIMIZATION LEAVES NO STONE UNTURNED Hackaday NEVER MISS A HACK Share Share Share Hackaday.io Hackaday.com This email was sent to why did I get this? Hackaday.com · 61 S Fair Oaks Ave Ste 200 · Pasadena, CA 91105-2270 · USA
Show all

The Latest Emails Sent By Hackaday

More Emails, Deals & Coupons From Hackaday

Email Offers, Discounts & Promos From Our Top Stores